Newest coworking space costs just $2.25 an hour, because it is a parking spot

79 points by localhostdotdev 6 years ago | 85 comments
  • s3r3nity 6 years ago
    Welcome to Silicon Valley: where everyone has somehow bamboozled themselves into believing that working in a cramped parking space is more valuable than buying office real estate in LITERALLY any other state...

    Remember kids: you don’t HAVE to live in California.

    • JohnJamesRambo 6 years ago
      The irony is that all the companies and startups work on internet companies which could happen anywhere with internet access. It's not like there is a gold mine under San Francisco streets that requires on site mining. And before you say "the people are the gold mine", those people could be interacted with remotely quite easily.
      • SubuSS 6 years ago
        I don't understand the push for remote work.

        I have been a part of remote teams for over 11 years of my career (16 yrs). I have worked from home more days than I can count. It has enough drawbacks that I'd avoid it at any given opportunity. Here are a few reasons:

        - You are not part of the hallway conversations / decision changes / fly by meetings / face-memory / kitchen run ins and every other benefit of having people together. When your level is senior enough, these are very much a deciding factor in whether your last 6 months of work is going to be thrown out or kept relevant.

        - Video conferencing is terrible. If you notice a pattern, the conversation is DOMINATED by the side with most power. I have seen very senior engineers (including myself I suppose) have trouble corralling a meeting / participating in a discussion that's going back and forth animatedly when there are other senior folk in one room. When you are junior, there is a high possibility your chances to speak are just perfunctory because almost all relevant points have been made already.

        - Yes I have heard and tried the notions of ensuring meeting etiquette. I have also been part of these meetings where there is someone (or everyone) trying to police how the meeting is run (let everyone speak, juniors go first, go in a circle ...). Those have been considerably less productive to put it mildly. (Remember - I am the one who is remote).

        - There are always mic-hogs who don't make a ton of points - most of the efficient places weed these out real quick. In a different rant - I hate optimizing for the bad actors that penalize the good actors heavily. Anyway - in this case you are left with few folks with real talking points not being able to convey the whole nuance.

        - Essentially this leads to you doing extra work in ensuring at least some folks on the other side are on the same page before the meeting to ensure your points are considered.

        So yes - in short remote is bad IMO. Video conferencing pretty much doesn't work since it doesn't capture the full presence and energy of folks. This is going to sound metaphysical, but my real presence is a million times better representation of the full me than my text/video :). It may work when everyone is remote with an individual screen - the usual situations I am in is where there are 2 or 3 conference rooms with people.

        • mawburn 6 years ago
          Having people work remote in a non-remote culture is a completely different experience than working with a fully remote culture.

          If the entire team/division/org doesn't fully embrace it, it usually just doesn't work. That doesn't mean everyone had to be remote, either.

          • dsfyu404ed 6 years ago
            Any team that spans several locations is going to have some/all of those issues anyway. Why make people suffer though living in a particular place on top of that?
            • ebiester 6 years ago
              The push is that some of us are led by life circumstances to do so. (For example, I am married to an academic with a tenure track position outside of a top-50 city.) My choices are to commute to another city or work remotely. (Coming home for the weekends sucks, by the way.) ____

              That said, I find that full remote works really well. Half-remote is a lot more difficult for the reasons you say, but encouraging all employees to work remote some of the time starts to equalize those issues, because everyone has the empathy of the experience.

              I've developed a set of coping strategies, but I agree that it's a tradeoff unless everyone is remote.

              • bluGill 6 years ago
                The only remote meetings that work are ones where everybody is remote. Even if you are sitting next to someone in the same meeting, your both have your headphones on so that you only hear each other via the call. As soon as there is a room there is a struggle in my experience: it is too easy talk to the people in the room.

                There is on type of in room meeting that works: the all employee meeting. The agenda is preset (first Joe will talk about goals, then Carla will go over financials, then Fred will update us on United way...).

              • sreyaNotfilc 6 years ago
                I saw 'San Francisco' and rolled my eyes. This is the dumbest idea I have seen in a while.

                What if someone runs you over trying to back into a spot? What if something falls from the sky (besides rain)? Or someone runs off with your equipment because your weren't looking? Or even, its a busy day and someone didn't reserve a parking spot.

                Putting your workers at risk because you're trying to save some dough is highly irresponsible.

                • nkrisc 6 years ago
                  Read the article. The primary point is activism. This isn't about money or saving costs at all. In fact the only mention of price was to pay the hourly parking rate, there's no mention of anyone collecting or making any other money on it. There's no formal system here, just some inspired activism to make a point about how much space is devoted to parking.
                  • Luc 6 years ago
                    Woosh!
                  • wDcBKgt66V8WDs 6 years ago
                    If you're a techie, young with no family, and you want good culture, good climate, good outdoors, and good job prospects...the valley is hard to beat.

                    Yes I know about droughts, we can debate all day if the culture is good or terrible, all these tech people are ruining the parks, yadayadayada. Point still stands, the san fran area has a unique and sought after position.

                    And to address your point about gold mine of people, not every company does the whole remote thing. I mean I agree remote shouldn't be hard but it's a legitimate position to prefer onsite employees.

                    • s3r3nity 6 years ago
                      > yadayadayada

                      You claim all of these to be unique characteristics, then wave off all reasonable (and in some cases, strong) arguments to the contrary that the Valley is hard to beat.

                      If it’s “hard to beat” because of X, Y, Z, and there are many other places with better examples of X, Y, and Z qualities, then there’s little about the position that should make SF “unique” or “sought after.”

                      Climate + outdoors + good job prospects are pretty much everywhere. In fact, you might be able to enjoy them more in other spots because of better commutes (less driving and/or better public transit,) better living conditions, and more purchasing power (lower prices on everything + lower rents / housing prices.)

                      But I guess the views are nice...?

                  • dcosson 6 years ago
                    Can’t tell if you’re serious but this was a joke/stunt. The point being to show how poor of a use of space it is to have street parking lining every street in an expensive and crowded city.
                    • chrisan 6 years ago
                      He may have taken it too literally... but he does have a point. Everyone doesn't _need_ to live in SF.

                      > proving two points: one about the high cost of coworking spaces in an already unaffordable city, and another about how the space currently dedicated to on-street parking in cramped cities like San Francisco could be put to better and more human-centric use.

                      You can reduce your cost of living/co-working by moving out of the city.

                      I can't imaging wanting to deal with fumes, electricity, weather, traffic dangers just to stay in the city by converting parking spots to more "human-centric" areas.

                      • dcosson 6 years ago
                        Again...it was a stunt. These were pro-housing folks but no one is suggesting directly turning parking into makeshift long term office space or housing. Human centric uses might include — protected bike lanes, trees so that the sidewalks feel further removed from cars, food trucks, outdoor cafe seating, etc.

                        Also, sure, not everyone needs to live in SF. But that’s a completely unrelated point. There are still people who do choose to live here and want to make the city a nicer place to live.

                      • zrobotics 6 years ago
                        Ironically, the pictures of one of the #wepark offices in the article was literally directly in front of empty commercial real estate for lease. What does this stunt prove, aside from being slightly silly? Should all the buildings be expanded by ~6',and the sidewalk moved directly adjacent to the road? Because even if personal automobiles are entirely eliminated, roads will still be necessary for access. As a tounge-in-cheek protest against high prices it works, but I think the grandparent is making a more salient point than the wepark group. If your job can be done from a temporary office environment (and many of the people interviewed already worked from their homes) then a far better solution to expensive real estate is to move, especially if you are already working remotely.

                        How much space can actually be reclaimed from on-street parking in a feasible manner? Likely not enough to make a significant difference in the price of real-estate.

                        • dcosson 6 years ago
                          Just a badly written article. The way I interpreted it (just having followed along a bit on twitter, I don't know these people personally) this particular thing is not directly about real estate. It's about better uses of outdoor/street space, focused on people rather than cars.

                          This is extremely valuable space, and it's rented out, far below its market value, by a city that claims to value environmental issues, to be put towards one of the worst offenders of carbon emissions (personal vehicles). It also adds to congestion and makes a city less enjoyable when the roads are wider and everything that isn't a car is a second class citizen.

                          Some better uses might be - more protected bike lanes, dedicated bus lanes, trees to offset the sidewalk further from the road or make sidewalks wider for a more vibrant, walkable street life.

                        • s3r3nity 6 years ago
                          Yeah I did catch on, but my read was that the conclusion of this stunt could drive thinking in a few directions.

                          One of the more popular directions would be to push for more building, and/or better transit options.

                          My recommendation was to push for more rational / sanity in the labor market choices: right now, it seems like it’s blasphemous to consider _NOT_ living in SF.

                          Rather than trying to push for enormous change at all levels, you can just say “nah there are better choices for me to live.”

                        • nafey 6 years ago
                          The other side of the coin is that a lot of very talented people congregate in places like Silicon Valley, so you rule out the potential of hiring/working for/working with them.
                          • cbm-vic-20 6 years ago
                            There are a lot of very talented people in places like Seattle and Boston, too, and yet the VCs and companies out in SF/SV are stuck in their little bubble.
                            • dsfyu404ed 6 years ago
                              Let them stay in their bubble. Every time CA vomits out a substantial number of upper-middle/upper class people it ruins another city, sometimes a whole state.
                            • JohnFen 6 years ago
                              Although SV culture seems to think otherwise, there are lots of very talented people across the rest of the nation as well. I've found them everywhere that I've worked.
                            • lalos 6 years ago
                              One could argue that this is the reason for why it's expensive, to limit the amount of people that can be there. The invisible hand at play.
                              • Johnny555 6 years ago
                                That doesn't really seem to be working -- people are coming but are doubling and tripling (and quadrupling) up in housing that wasn't meant to accommodate them.

                                Of course, that's nothing new - I rented a large closet (literally a closet) when I first moved to SF over 2 decades ago. Eventually I got promoted to the formal dining room (which unfortunately was the walkway from the bedrooms to the livingroom, but still beat living in a closet!)

                              • 6 years ago
                              • pseudolus 6 years ago
                                In a similar vein I'm working on an idea to monetize cemetery plots and crypts in and around San Francisco. They're quiet workplaces with scenic views (lots of flowers and greenery), often centrally located and many are close to coffee shops. With a little cabling/wiring and some temporary structures they would make ideal workplaces.
                                • xtracto 6 years ago
                                  You might be half kidding. But one thing I loved in the UK was that people went to cemetery to jog. That is a great multifunctional use of a plot of land.

                                  I live pretty close to a cemetery, however due to cultural customs, I would never think of going there to jog. Unfortunately, there is no other place nearby my house were I could go jogging.

                                  • stronglikedan 6 years ago
                                    > they would make ideal workplaces

                                    I'm not sure ideal is the right word, but I get your drift.

                                    • derp_dee_derp 6 years ago
                                      I think you are missing the whole point of cemeteries and crypts: to honor the dead. They are not parks. They are not nature preserves. They are not just quiet places with scenic views. They are memorials to those who have gone before.

                                      Turning a place of honor into an office space kinda defeats the whole point and is super disrespectful.

                                      • viklove 6 years ago
                                        I'm pretty sure the comment you're replying to was sarcastic.
                                      • 6 years ago
                                      • jontaydev 6 years ago
                                        Has anybody tried to create something like AirBnB for co-working/office spaces? There must be people willing to rent out a spare bedroom they never use, etc. All you really need to provide is a desk and internet.
                                        • jeswin 6 years ago
                                          This is an excellent idea! Letting out the entire apartment or most of it could make for a better experience, since part of the appeal (for many) is the community and a break from solo working environments. One could make an app where users could see coworker profiles etc - might appeal to people looking for inspiration or motivation.
                                          • lprubin 6 years ago
                                            This company does that with extra office space: https://liquidspace.com/share-office-meeting-space

                                            They have a Slack integration that can ping you when somebody places a request that matches your availability.

                                            • s3r3nity 6 years ago
                                              A lot of states have laws against office and living spaces being in the same building, if I recall. Maybe someone else has more expertise and correct me.

                                              This would obviously make it difficult for someone to rent out their living room to $Startup, for example.

                                              • Scoundreller 6 years ago
                                                Did Uber let local laws strangle its business? NO!

                                                Did Airbnb let local laws strangle its business? NO!

                                                Did PayPal let money transmitter licenses and rampant fraud strangle its business? NO!

                                                Did YouTube let rampant piracy strangle its business? NO!

                                                Now go start your residential hot-desking business!!’

                                                • cjsawyer 6 years ago
                                                  I guess the moral is that if you make enough money fast enough, you can hire lawyers to keep you out of jail.
                                              • vegannet 6 years ago
                                                There is such a startup in London (and elsewhere maybe) but the problem is the costs are greater than the cost of a true co-working space. WeWork in London has hot desks from about £10/day (monthly) and £20/day (pay as you go). A homeowner isn’t going to let someone use their home all day to make a few £.

                                                https://www.vrumi.com/

                                                • Cthulhu_ 6 years ago
                                                  > A homeowner isn’t going to let someone use their home all day to make a few £.

                                                  Are you sure? I mean if I had the space and situation (that is, an office room separate from the rest of the house, e.g. a garage) it's something I'd consider. It probably doesn't fall under hotel / lodging laws either.

                                                  • vegannet 6 years ago
                                                    You’re looking at 1/10th of the earnings you’d generate from AirBnB with the same amount of work. You have to manage bookings, grant access (working around your own availability), handle insurance and clean up. Would you deal with all of that for less than £10/day once or twice a week? The pitch makes sense for larger spaces that can accommodate teams — like the examples on the site — but for individuals there’s no value.
                                                • duxup 6 years ago
                                                  I always wondered that. I worked at a few places where we ended up with too much space.... seemed wasteful.

                                                  You'll want to maybe be a bit careful about who you rent to, but still seems like that would be useful.

                                                  Personally I'd be more interested in renting out a small space from a larger company or even campus than one space out of numerous rental spaces where I've got no idea what is going on each day.

                                                  • dublo7 6 years ago
                                                    Airbnb does this already. I used to work remote and they have digital nomad housing... Specially WiFi and private workspace as part of the amenities you can require.
                                                    • ryanSrich 6 years ago
                                                      Workfrom seems to be pivoting to something like this https://workfrom.co/homebase
                                                      • localhostdotdev 6 years ago
                                                        exactly what I was thinking, e.g. "need a working space anywhere? just use the app and rent a one of our free spaces or share one"

                                                        I could definitely see VC money going into this, maybe even an existing company doing it.

                                                        the parking spots could have temporary structures to make it more like an office, have plugs, internet, etc.

                                                        then it could expand globally and it's no issue if it's outlawed in one city/country, just go to the next city/country.

                                                        • jontaydev 6 years ago
                                                          I’ll start my YC application :) But in reality, the legal issues that s3r3nity mentioned would be a big problem for residential. Maybe this could be marketed to existing commercial spaces that have an extra room they don’t use.

                                                          As somebody who works remotely, having an app that finds a place to work wold be a dream.

                                                        • JohnFen 6 years ago
                                                          > All you really need to provide is a desk and internet.

                                                          Depending on your city, there may be zoning restrictions about such use.

                                                        • lprubin 6 years ago
                                                          $2.25/hr for 8 hours is $18. I don't know about the SF prices but in Manhattan you can get a "hot desk" for $30/day at some fairly nice places. I'd guess in Brooklyn you can probably find/negotiate something comparable to $18/hr.
                                                          • candu 6 years ago
                                                            I was just going to say the same - and $18 / day * 21-ish working days per month is...$400 / month.

                                                            Hey, that's roughly what a coworking office space costs! Except sitting in a parking spot, you don't get free wifi, coffee / tea, bathrooms, networking events, shelter from the elements, facilities security / maintenance...

                                                            So: I'm not sure how coworking fits into the larger point they're trying to make. Yes, residential rent is insane in San Francisco - no argument there. Yes, parking spaces that sit unused throughout most of the day are an unfortunate legacy of car-centric urban design. Both of these are solid and reasonable points to make.

                                                            But $400 / month for an office space that comes with a slew of amenities? That seems entirely reasonable to me, and definitely in keeping with permanent desk costs in other, less extravagantly priced cities.

                                                            • snarf21 6 years ago
                                                              The best part of co-working spaces is that the cost scales completely linearly without signing multi-year leases and deposits and all the other logistics of having an office.
                                                            • RandallBrown 6 years ago
                                                              You can get a hot desk for $30/person/day. This parking spot is only $2.25 for as many people as you can fit in it.
                                                              • zrobotics 6 years ago
                                                                What confusese is that anytime the open-office concept is mentioned it seems that nearly nobody is in favor of it, yet that is the model employed by most coworking spaces. I can't imagine trying to actually be productive in most of those environments.
                                                                • JohnFen 6 years ago
                                                                  > I can't imagine trying to actually be productive in most of those environments.

                                                                  I know from experience that I can't, and that's one reason why things like WeWork would not be something that I'd consider. I wouldn't even take a position with a company that uses an open office plan.

                                                                  But there are apparently a large enough number of people who find that sort of thing tolerable that a business catering to them appears viable.

                                                              • 6 years ago
                                                                • dsfyu404ed 6 years ago
                                                                  $18 for a workday is bargain pricing for parking in the Boston area.
                                                                • WD-42 6 years ago
                                                                  This is a fantastic demonstration of how poorly we manage our streets. There is no doubt in my mind that in the future we will look back at how we currently treat parking and wonder "What took so long?"

                                                                  I wonder if anyone has ever calculated the amount of actual acreage taken up by street parking in San Francisco. Undoubtedly it's a huge amount that you would consider extremely valuable in a place like San Francisco. Yet we're letting people dump their single passenger vehicles in public and it's no big deal.

                                                                  • slashcom 6 years ago
                                                                    That is the actual plot of the SheWork episode in Broad City.
                                                                  • cowpewter 6 years ago
                                                                    That makes me wonder what else you could repurpose as an office in places where offices are disproportionally expensive. What about a climate-controlled storage unit? A quick Googling tells me you can get a small (but large enough for a desk) climate controlled storage unit in San Fran for about $100-150/month. That's vastly cheaper than a co-working space. I know you can get storage units with power, they're pretty popular as practice spaces for bands around where I live. You'd need a mobile hotspot for internet, and no windows might be a bit depressing, but for the price...
                                                                    • Invictus0 6 years ago
                                                                      Met a guy in DC that actually lived inside a warehouse storage unit. He had installed lights, walls for multiple bedrooms, a kitchen/bar, and a lot of cool art. I'm awful at estimating distances but I'd guess the main room was about 800sqft and the bedrooms/bathrooms were divided from another 400sqft. With a little love, any place can become a home.
                                                                      • JohnFen 6 years ago
                                                                        Major props for the Snow Crash approach!

                                                                        Every warehouse/storage unit I've ever leased has included terms that specifically prohibited doing that, though. You might be able to get away with it for a while, but you should always be prepared to be evicted.

                                                                        • fyfy18 6 years ago
                                                                          I haven't ever seem a storage unit with plumbing before...
                                                                          • dsfyu404ed 6 years ago
                                                                            I think he meant rented warehouse space, not an actual storage unit. Storage units rarely have more than a single electrical outlet and many lower end ones don't even have that.
                                                                            • zrobotics 6 years ago
                                                                              Most of the plumbing technology developed for RV 'boondocking' would be perfectly adequate. Bit of a PITA, but I've done that for 2.5 week stretches in the mountains on ~1 gallon/day of H2O. My real concern would be no windows, definitely not great for anyone who suffers from seasonal affective disorder.
                                                                              • cowpewter 6 years ago
                                                                                Water tanks filled from outside and a composting toilet maybe?
                                                                            • amelius 6 years ago
                                                                              But is that legal?
                                                                              • cowpewter 6 years ago
                                                                                Probably about as legal as setting up office in a street-side parking space...
                                                                            • gumby 6 years ago
                                                                              Was the reporter too credulous or were they in on the joke?
                                                                              • Abishek_Muthian 6 years ago
                                                                                They should invest in getting those large collapsable umbrellas for shade, working in 'on-road parking' during summer doesn't sound practical.
                                                                                • Cthulhu_ 6 years ago
                                                                                  Or an RV or van converted to an office space.
                                                                                  • JohnFen 6 years ago
                                                                                    I did this (in an RV) for a few years in my younger days, when starting my first business. It worked very, very well for me and came with the added benefit that I could move my office any time I wanted to be in a place that was more convenient or enjoyable.
                                                                                    • Abishek_Muthian 6 years ago
                                                                                      I think the motive of this group is to organise people to the streets with bare minimum costs, sounds more like an agenda to show that it's possible than to be a practical working space.
                                                                                  • localhostdotdev 6 years ago
                                                                                    the website: https://www.wepark.us

                                                                                    the original twitter thread (first test drive): https://twitter.com/VictorPontis/status/1121521771633500160

                                                                                    • Scoundreller 6 years ago
                                                                                      It’s $2.75/hr. Talk about inflation!
                                                                                    • keeganjw 6 years ago
                                                                                      Good on them for bringing attention to how much space is wasted for parking in cities! A clever way to raise awareness.
                                                                                      • Luc 6 years ago
                                                                                        Apparently a bit too clever for a lot of people, going by many of the comments here.
                                                                                      • zck 6 years ago
                                                                                        The group Improv Everywhere did a similar thing, playing it more for laughs: https://improveverywhere.com/2018/11/13/phone-booth-coworkin...
                                                                                        • Tomte 6 years ago
                                                                                          Twenty people working in a space about the size of a parking spot? I call bullshit.
                                                                                          • ebg13 6 years ago
                                                                                            It's almost like there are photos in the article or something.
                                                                                            • Tomte 6 years ago
                                                                                              Great! I count five, with a sixth standing aside.
                                                                                          • amelius 6 years ago
                                                                                            I've seen someone being literally bumped out of a parking spot by a car, because the driver wanted to park there.
                                                                                            • larrydag 6 years ago
                                                                                              I hope they have the added cost of theft, vandalism, and medical. That looks really risky.
                                                                                              • jotm 6 years ago
                                                                                                This is getting ridiculous.
                                                                                                • phalangion 6 years ago
                                                                                                  That appears to be the point.
                                                                                                • humanbeinc 6 years ago
                                                                                                  What a time we live in...