Show HN: Excalideck β Use Excalidraw to make slides
125 points by pscanf 3 years ago | 24 comments- pscanf 3 years agoHello HN, here's an open source app I've been working on for the past few weeks.
I love Excalidraw[1], the virtual whiteboard (discussed recently here on HN[2]). Its UX is great - simple and intuitive - and really makes it easy for me to express my thoughts and explain complex concepts with a quick sketch. I want to use it to make slides!
However Excalidraw is not specifically designed for that. I used it for that many times actually, but the workflow is quite cumbersome: drawing a same-sized perimeter for each slide, adding to each slide watermarks and other common elements, exporting each slide as PNG into a powerpoint... it takes a long time!
So well, here's Excalideck to simplify that workflow. :)
It's still in early development, so it's not very polished. But you're welcome to give it a try, make some slides, and let me know how it goes!
[1] https://excalidraw.com [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29109995
- boberoni 3 years agoVery cool! Even though the name suggests that Excalideck is for slide presentations, this is incredibly useful for me to organize multiple Excalidraw canvases for personal use. I often create system architecture diagrams that are separate but related. Rather than having to scroll around the infinite Excalidraw canvas or use multiple Excalidraw links (which I organize in a Google doc), now I can just flip through Excalideck slides. Small but very convenient
- yesimahuman 3 years agoExalidraw+ makes managing multiple designs easy and itβs only $7/mo (last I checked). Happy to support the product!
- pscanf 3 years agoOh, nice use case actually. Makes me think that a button to hide/collapse the slides miniatures might be useful then, to give more real estate to the drawing board.
- dangoor 3 years agoAlong these lines, it'd be nice to be able to make part of the diagram a hyperlink to another slide. (And the next thing you know, you've got folks making UX mockups in Excalideck, just like they do with Keynote/Powerpoint!)
- pscanf 3 years agoInteresting! Added it as a possible future feature[1].
[1] https://github.com/excalideck/excalideck/issues/34
> And the next thing you know, you've got folks making UX mockups in Excalideck, just like they do with Keynote/Powerpoint!
Excalimock :P , could become a whole suite of tools!
- pscanf 3 years ago
- dangoor 3 years ago
- yesimahuman 3 years ago
- stuzenz 3 years agoI like it - I am also a fan of Excaldraw.
I noticed some kind of error coming up in trying to export to pdf - other than that it seems to be working well.
I am using the following set up ``` uname -a Linux arch-t460p 5.14.16-arch1-1 #1 SMP PREEMPT Tue, 02 Nov 2021 22:22:59 +0000 x86_64 GNU/Linux (base) ~ via π base firefox --version Mozilla Firefox 94.0
```
I am not sure, but this message that pops up seems to suggest that it might not be establishing a good naming convention for the save.
``` application/vdn.excalideck+pdf (92.6 KB) ```
I will put an issue on the github project if I see it persists in the next day or two.
Thanks for sharing - great work! Between presentation tools like this and reveal-md we have some nice options for building out presentations.
Thinking about it. It would be great if it was possible to export each of the slides as independent png/svg as well. That would allow some possibilities to open up for using it with reveal-md
- pscanf 3 years ago> I noticed some kind of error coming up in trying to export to pdf
Ah sorry, not entirely unexpected actually, as for the moment the saving/loading functionality on Firefox and Safari is a bit broken.
The functionality relies on a newish Web API only fully supported by Chrome / Edge, and I haven't implemented proper fallbacks yet (the plan is to make an Electron app, which fully allows working with local files, but an adequate fallback should be provided for all browsers regardless).
> It would be great if it was possible to export each of the slides as independent png/svg as well.
Definitely an option. Supporting different export formats is on the horizon. Feel free to open an issue / discussion about independent png/svg as well!
- pscanf 3 years ago
- arendtio 3 years agoI like it, but is there a presentation mode? So far I found fullscreen and zen-mode, but it was still showing the slide overview.
It would be awesome if it would be using the JS API for presentations!
- pscanf 3 years agoSee my reply[1] to another comment, but basically not yet, but it's a planned feature[2].
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29141090 [2] https://github.com/excalideck/excalideck/issues/29
- arendtio 3 years agoThanks, for the answer. I find the PDF export a valid option too, but did not notice that it actually exports an PDF via the save button.
Keep up the great work :-)
- arendtio 3 years ago
- pscanf 3 years ago
- avinassh 3 years agoIn the past I have used Excalidraw Slides [0], which is open source [1] too. Any chance you looked into this as well?
- Fnoord 3 years agoI would appreciate an official Docker image. It also helps with a consistant dev env
- pscanf 3 years agoHaven't thought about the self-hosting story yet (or rather, I thought more in the direction of a desktop Electron app), but definitely an option. Added an issue[1].
- pscanf 3 years ago
- omk 3 years agoLoved it.
Is there no way to start a slideshow? As in fullscreen slides? If there is such a control, it isn't obvious to me. If it isn't would be awesome to have it.
- pscanf 3 years agoNot yet, but it's planned for the ~future[1].
For the MVP I though it'd be ok for the user to save the pdf file and use their OS viewer to present it. :)
- pscanf 3 years ago
- bertman 3 years agoThis looks very nice and useful, thanks! Bookmarked :D
- sgt 3 years agoWhen loading a library I get an error "There was an error loading the third party library." Using Safari on macOS.
- pscanf 3 years agoYes, it's a known bug[1] on all browsers. For the MVP I decided not to fix it, as copying-pasting from Excalidraw works, so there's a workaround for it.
- pscanf 3 years ago
- amitoz_azad 3 years agoThis is amazing! As a student I am always looking for tools to make good presentations fast. Wonderful !
However, I am wondering is there any way to add equations through latex of mathjx? Write now I feel that only way to include equations is via images or hand draw them.
- factorialboy 3 years agoThis is great. I'd love an electron app, excalitron?
- pscanf 3 years agoThanks! Yes, it's a planned feature for the next iteration[1].
- pscanf 3 years ago
- zekenie 3 years agoThis is amazing and I will use this.
- pscanf 3 years agoThanks, glad you like it!
- pscanf 3 years ago