Miracle escape as burning plane lands at Tokyo airport after collision
46 points by ahachete 1 year ago | 9 comments- ChrisArchitect 1 year ago[dupe]
More discussion over here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38839885
- dang 1 year agoThanks! We moved most comments to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38841708 since that one seems to have a better article.
- dang 1 year ago
- k8sToGo 1 year agoThat title does not sound correct. The plane was not landing burning. It hit a plane while landing and then started to burn.
- top_sigrid 1 year ago
- gizajob 1 year agoI personally hate every invocation of the idea of miracles in the popular press and discourse. You know what’s a better miracle? Not having the plane crash.
- clan 1 year agoWould it not be a little blasé to simple describe it as "evacuation happened as per procedure". Even if we sprinkle "successfully" into the sentence?
While I am not a religious person and hence does not care for some of the connotation in the word - I find it hard to find a more descriptive word in this case.
Neither do I believe any magic happens when all the stars align. But I do like it as a poetic rewrite of "simple luck".
So I understand your beef but you offer no alternative.
Best case outcome in a though situation does not have the same ring to it.
- jltsiren 1 year agoMaybe people have different connotations associated with the word "miracle".
I interpret a miracle escape as something like "nobody had any idea what to do, but by miracle, everyone survived". The alternative would be "the flight crew did what they were trained to do, the process worked, and everyone survived". Here the difference between a miracle and procedure is the difference between luck and competence.
- jltsiren 1 year ago
- YPPH 1 year agoI do agree it's inappropriate when it is invoked in reference to divine intervention. But not when it is simply used to describe something extraordinary. Take "Miracle on the Hudson" - I think it's fair there, it's incredible every person survived a water ditching. Miracle is a fair word to use.
- bloomingeek 1 year agoI agree, using the word miracle is an expression that can be either religious or anything you want. The people complaining probably love to pick fly crap out of pepper too. (sorry, an old expression the old timers used to tell me.)
- bloomingeek 1 year ago
- clan 1 year ago