If you get the chance, always run more extra network fiber cabling

230 points by hggh 3 months ago | 244 comments
  • msarrel 3 months ago
    Yup, always run extra everything. At least you can splice fiber now. And be careful of the minimum bend radius.

    Once, in the 90s, we were having intermittent network failures in our data center. I kept trying to troubleshoot it with the fluke, but the problem kept moving. When I pulled up the raised floor, I discovered that rats were eating the exterior sheath of the network cables. That was some fun troubleshooting!

    • DannyBee 3 months ago
      "And be careful of the minimum bend radius."

      The minimum bend radius of any good fiber is way less than cat6 at this point.

      G.657A1/B1 = 10mm

      G.657A2/B2 = 7.5mm

      G.657A3/B3= 2.5mm

      CAT6 = 25mm

      Flexible cat6 = 15mm.

      Fiber surpassed copper for flexibility almost 2 decades ago (G.657 was introduced in 2006, but let's call it 5 years before all forms became common).

      Even G.652 was only 25mm and standardized in 1984.

      • Dylan16807 3 months ago
        It takes less force to bend, though.
        • mrheosuper 3 months ago
          could be solved by running reinforce wire along it
        • kuschku 3 months ago
          I accidentally put a knot in a fiber, and it still worked. I'm still using it today, 3 years later (after untying the knot, ofc).
          • walrus01 3 months ago
            for an example of how good modern g.657 bend loss insensitive fiber is, for ftth applications and drop/last hundred meters, here's an example of it being abused with a staple gun and the resulting loss in dB.

            https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4wzJSInvww

            the above is from 12 years ago

            I've seen some g.657.b3 patch cords and work done for FTTH installs that are absolutely atrocious and yet continue to function properly.

            • mrb 3 months ago
              This video is a cool demo. Trying to eyeball it, it seems all of the bend radii (except one) are over 10-20mm so this demo isn't that impressive. The only exception is the very last bend he makes with the weight where the radius is probably around 5mm. I find this ironic that when making this last bend is exactly when the video abruptly ends with some video corruption artifacts. As if they streamed the recording over this fiber :-)
              • Gareth321 3 months ago
                This is proprietary technology and is definitely NOT representative of normal fibre cables. I know because I had had to deal with contractors doing exactly this, which crushed the cables we ran. There are many things which could be better if we were willing to pay higher prices for them. At the end of the day, cheap and good enough usually wins.
                • DannyBee 3 months ago
                  As i'm sure you know - for invisible installs, they don't even bother to have an outer cable anymore, just the 250um fiber with no sheath running bare on the walls.

                  Kinda insane.

              • pavelstoev 3 months ago
                And clean the fiber connector ends with a special cloth or cleaning liquid. Once, I had an intermittent link due to dust particles.

                Fun fact 1: When you don't have a proper OTDR fiber tester to check for breaks, you can shine a laser pointer down the fiber and see it projected out on a sheet of paper on the other end (you might have to call the person on the other end).

                Fun fact 2: If the other end is plugged into a transceiver, don't look at the fiber end directly; instead, look at it through your phone camera. If all is working correctly, you should be able to see a faint purple light out of one of the strands.

                P.S. always remember to roll it if no link initially :)

                • traceroute66 3 months ago
                  > If the other end is plugged into a transceiver, don't look at the fiber end directly

                  Let me fix that for you.

                  Don't look at the fiber end directly, always assume it is plugged in unless you can see the other end yourself with your own eyes.

                  Fibre light meters can be bought cheaply for a basic troubleshooting bag kit-out if you don't fancy splashing out on a fancy device.

                  • rowanG077 3 months ago
                    The last one may not work anymore. A ton of phones nowadays have IR filters.
                    • moron4hire 3 months ago
                      They all do and always have, they just aren't perfect.
                      • pavelstoev 3 months ago
                        works on my iphone 13
                    • whycome 3 months ago
                      Your typical Rodent Accelerated Transmission Signal And System Suppression
                      • liotier 3 months ago
                        > Yup, always run extra everything

                        Cables ain't free, duct capacity is finite and duct rental from the local incumbent is costly too... Please calculate the financial optimum of pay now vs. pay later - taking into account growth, various forms of attrition, cost of capital, opportunity costs and appetite for risk. Or everyone would be running 1152 strands cables everywhere.

                        But then I see that from a telco perspective and, now that I've read the article, it seems to be from a small-scale hosting perspective - entirely different economics.

                        • terribleperson 3 months ago
                          Duct capacity is finite, but fiber cables are tiny and they are very nearly free compared to the cost of having them run.
                          • liotier 3 months ago
                            Not quite tiny - a basic armored (rats !) 12 strands cable may be around 10-15 millimeters, whereas similarly specced cables in the 500 strands range might reach 20-30 mm. In crowded Paris downtown, it adds up fast. On the countryside, that is a lot more weight to hang on poles.
                          • ghaff 3 months ago
                            And while some people preach hard-wired everything I’d probably increasingly not bother at home. . I’ll have to see how much networking and audio stuff I even do given a kitchen fire with s
                            • jaxn 3 months ago
                              Maybe in an apartment. In a house, you want wired backhaul on access points, and wired streaming devices.
                            • dwattttt 3 months ago
                              Or, take the money you would spend calculating that, and that's the amount you spend for your margin.
                              • liotier 3 months ago
                                Haha, I'll tell that to the outside plant capacity planning team !

                                But seriously, I'm telco-biased, and it seems that the article has a small scale hosting... Different worlds. At small scale, sure - the bigger cable is a rounding error.

                            • _JamesA_ 3 months ago
                              Have fusion splicers come down in price? Can you recommend any?
                              • DannyBee 3 months ago
                                You don't need them unless you are running a mile or two of fiber - mechanical fast connectors (IE no polish, etc) are less than 0.3db loss at this point.

                                Fusion splicing will still be 0.01db or better, but you will be well within the power budget of any transceiver you find with mechanical connectors, if we are talking home networking - even a 2km 10gb transceiver that is 20 bucks has a 6db power budget.

                                Heck, the 10km are cheaper than 2km at this point - 17bucks on amazon, power budget of 16db.

                                • sponaugle 3 months ago
                                  This is VERY true - especially for home use. You could have many db of loss and still have a perfectly functional 100g network.
                                • mmastrac 3 months ago
                                  AliExpress sells some basic ones from $300-700 CAD ($200-500 USD) with reasonable reviews.

                                  Whatever you do, don't try using the razor-style "hand splicers" and adhesive splice kits. Without a splicer that has a scope, you're just making bets each time that are difficult to test.

                                  I've learned the hard way that it's just not worth it unless you can _see_ what you're working on.

                                  • sponaugle 3 months ago
                                    I have a $1000 fusion splicer from Amazon, and it is fantastic. It is very straightforward to use, and for my home use it is perfect. If I did spicing as a job this wouldn't be the tool to use, but for occasional splices in my homelab it works great.

                                    https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CW2HGVT2?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_...

                                    • tw_wankette 3 months ago
                                      For Multimode, they now make splices where you jam the two cleaved ends into the splice. It costs about $5 per splice.
                                      • Faaak 3 months ago
                                        You can have them second hand for ~500€ on ebay
                                        • tonetegeatinst 3 months ago
                                          Any advice on making sure you get a good splicer?

                                          I know a little about fiber connectors, and the different connector modules for speed, but I am not really sure what I need for a splicer for fiber.

                                      • cyptus 3 months ago
                                        _minimum_ bend?
                                        • zygentoma 3 months ago
                                          minimum bend _radius_

                                          A straight cable has an infinite radius, the more bend the smaller the radius

                                          • hinkley 3 months ago
                                            Though if it is on or under the surface of the earth, “straight” will be a bend radius of around 6,370km. We don’t make a lot of buildings that deal with this but transcontinental or transoceanic cables certainly do. If someone designed a fiber that required absolutely no bend in order to work you’d have to use it in buildings or dig much deeper holes.

                                            There was an encoding mechanism proposed about 10-15 years ago that used spirally polarized light to carry more channels, but it required the surface of the fiber to be polished to a much higher degree than existing cables in order for the light to go around bends properly.

                                          • numpad0 3 months ago
                                            Fibers can be bent to a radius of an inch or so, that's the tolerated minimum bend radius.

                                            I guess you could call it "the maximum sharpness tangency" or something like that, but that's not the standard verbiage.

                                            • DannyBee 3 months ago
                                              G.657A1, which is basically the crappiest you would ever buy at this point, is not even half an inch bend radius.
                                            • Etheryte 3 months ago
                                              Minimum bend radius.
                                              • quickthrowman 3 months ago
                                                It’s usually 20x the outer diameter of the cable for fiber, a cable with a .3 inch OD has a 6 inch minimum bend radius.
                                                • DannyBee 3 months ago
                                                  What?

                                                  This is 100% wrong.

                                                  This is well standardized. As I posted elsewhere:

                                                  G.657A1/B1 = 10mm (half an inch)

                                                  G.657A2/B2 = 7.5mm (a little over a quarter inch)

                                                  G.657A3/B3 = 2.5mm (less than 1/8th of an inch)

                                                  The only cable you will find with a 6 inch bend radius is going to be armored interlocking fiber cable or something.

                                                  You can take 2mm G657.A3 fiber cable, wrap it around a pencil, and it will work 100% fine.

                                                  Even old G652 cable only had a 1 inch bend radius.

                                            • bhouston 3 months ago
                                              Yeah, we got a new house built 4 years ago and one of the biggest regrets is not enough ethernet outlets (running fibre in the house isn't practical yet) and power outlets in various places. It is really hard to think of all the places you would want them ahead of time unfortunately and as each has a cost you don't want to incur it unnecessarily.

                                              But my biggest regrets were:

                                              - Only a single ethernet port in the basement. Then the kid wanted a gaming station and we moved where the TV was. I should have put like 4 down there.

                                              - No ethernet ports in the garage, I should have put in one for an AP.

                                              - 4 ceiling APs instead of just two in the main part of the house. I over-estimated how much coverage I would get from ceiling APs and thus I have some APs hidden under furniture to ensure 100% house coverage.

                                              - Lack of multiple circuits in the garage, even better a separate sub-panel with 6 outlets. I took up wood working and with a single circuit and 2 outlets was insufficient. That cost me $1200 for the sub-panel.

                                              - Multiple outlets on the back and side of the house - I would have done two at the front on each side and two at the back on side each and one on each side of the house. I have a single outlet at the front and back and that is just not sufficient for lights, decorations and patio devices.

                                              • SeaGully 3 months ago
                                                For anyone else reading personally ceiling APs can't be overstated. My father-in-law is crazy about internet, but I've realized he was crazy like a fox when we did our to-the-studs renovation. He treated APs like a fire alarm or a CO monitor: one per room.

                                                My brother-in-law thinks he's crazy, and obviously it only really works if it is practical to run the wire and you can afford the number, but for my relatively small house it is insane how little I think about my internet. It is one of those quality of life things I never would have realized with having someone come and do it for me.

                                                I guess the only thing is some of the ceilings get a little crowded with lights + fire alarm + CO alarm + HVAC in/out + AP, so for small rooms it can be a challenge to figure out where to put things. But in that case I mean ... you don't need one per room. My father-in-law is crazy like a fox ... but he's also a little crazy like a crazy person.

                                                • mjevans 3 months ago
                                                  IMO a not-tiny house should have several sub-panels: Kitchen (enough to run the big stove + ~100A, but every outlet it's own 20A circuit), 'lab' / workshop (same idea), laundry room (lock-out breaker near / in room for connecting / disconnecting), etc.

                                                  A family member who's doing better in life than I am purchased a house built within the last 5 years, and it didn't even _have_ Ethernet run anywhere. WHY!?! I can't fathom how it's possible anyone would find that a negative.

                                                  • nkurz 3 months ago
                                                    > A family member who's doing better in life than I am purchased a house built within the last 5 years, and it didn't even _have_ Ethernet run anywhere. WHY!?! I can't fathom how it's possible anyone would find that a negative.

                                                    I'm less sure. Are there any 40 year old cables that you'd consider a positive in your house today? 20 year old cables? I wouldn't be too excited about having a house full of Coax, 10Base-T, and twisted pair.

                                                    I feel like the much better solution is to run conduit in which you can replace the cable rather than permanently putting in twice as much of whatever is in favor today. The conduit is always better, right?

                                                    • epiccoleman 3 months ago
                                                      > 20 year old cables?

                                                      I just bought a new house and the previous owner had phone lines everywhere (bedrooms, kitchen, office, rec room - honestly kind of weird). The house was built in 2002 and I gather that it was common at that time to put in Cat5e and just not use all the pairs.

                                                      So all it took was a pleasant afternoon with the circuit toner, a new patch panel, and a few keystone jacks, and now the house is networked beautifully. Sure, they're not in exactly the places I'd have dropped 'em if I'd been starting from scratch, but it's hard to beat cables already in the wall for zero effort!

                                                      • myself248 3 months ago
                                                        20 years is not that long ago.

                                                        30 years ago I was pulling cat5 into office building ceilings. Some of it is still there, still relevant. GigE runs just fine over it (most of it turned out to meet cat5e spec anyway), and very few applications on the desktop need more than gig.

                                                        Conduit is always better, but cat5 has proven to have a surprisingly long relevance.

                                                        • terribleperson 3 months ago
                                                          Cat6 is twenty years old and still entirely usable today in a residential setting.
                                                          • IncreasePosts 3 months ago
                                                            I was thankful I bought a house full of coax recently - now I have MoCA 2.5 adapters installed in the living room/kitchen/office/den/bedrooms all connecting to a central coax manifold which became my server room - this lets me hit ~2Gbps. Sure, cat6 would have been better, but that was 30 years from being invented when my house was built.
                                                            • bhouston 3 months ago
                                                              Yeah, conduit makes sense. The future in homes - from this current vantage point - is likely all wireless via multiple APs around the house that have short range but very high bandwidth. Only us power users will have wired ethernet.
                                                            • kelnos 3 months ago
                                                              > MO a not-tiny house should have several sub-panels: Kitchen (enough to run the big stove + ~100A, but every outlet it's own 20A circuit)

                                                              This seems like crazy overkill. Certainly there are kitchen appliances that devour power, but... what? Assuming an electric stove/oven, you really just need one dedicated circuit for that, and then everything else can run off another circuit. If you expect to use a microwave often, you might want it on its own circuit, but everything else you might have (blender, mixer, toaster, coffee/espresso machine, electric kettle, etc.) will run just fine on a single circuit.

                                                              And regardless, you don't need a sub-panel for this. All of these can run just fine as separate circuits off your main panel.

                                                              • tguvot 3 months ago
                                                                In usa at least in area where i live code requires dedicated circuits for most of kitchen appliances
                                                            • nkrisc 3 months ago
                                                              > Only a single ethernet port in the basement. Then the kid wanted a gaming station and we moved where the TV was. I should have put like 4 down there.

                                                              https://store.ui.com/us/en/category/all-switching/products/u...

                                                              Unless you meant with regards to routing the cables throughout the space, like now it’s on the opposite wall from the port.

                                                              I’ve definitely shoved cables under baseboards, but you can also pull them off and the run the cable in the wall behind them. You don’t even need to patch the drywall then. You can also get baseboards (that look nice in a home) then double as cable runs.

                                                              • bhouston 3 months ago
                                                                > You can also get baseboards (that look nice in a home) then double as cable runs.

                                                                Interesting. That would be great in the basement. I will look into it.

                                                                • hobs 3 months ago
                                                                  Dont forget Powerline adapters - if you have it all on one loop they are surprisingly effective if you have extra power sockets!
                                                                  • tguvot 3 months ago
                                                                    Take a look at orac decor. They have special baseboards for this
                                                                • ajsnigrutin 3 months ago
                                                                  That's why pretty much every office space/building over here has cable trunking/channels on the walls instead of fixed wiring, eg:

                                                                  https://www.elba.si/izdelki/parapetni-kanali/

                                                                  https://www.obo.si/izdelki/izdelkiinstalacije-v-zgradbah/bis...

                                                                  Need one more outlet? Remove the plastic cover, insert cable, insert outlet, cut the plastic cover to make space for outlet, and you're done.

                                                                • david422 3 months ago
                                                                  > Only a single ethernet port in the basement. Then the kid wanted a gaming station and we moved where the TV was. I should have put like 4 down there.

                                                                  Just drop a switch down there.

                                                                  • bhouston 3 months ago
                                                                    I have, but now I have cable running along the base boards. That isn't optimal. Also I have 10G networking, so the ethernet switches are hot and expensive.
                                                                    • throwaway2037 3 months ago

                                                                          > Also I have 10G networking, so the ethernet switches are hot and expensive.
                                                                      
                                                                      I never understand why anyone needs anything faster than 1G (other than to flex for Internet points). Seriously, how often do you need to move data faster than 100MB/s? Almost never. FYI: A 2.5G switch should be fine. There are many fan-less options here: https://www.servethehome.com/the-ultimate-cheap-2-5gbe-switc...
                                                                      • npodbielski 3 months ago
                                                                        I was thinking about this and it is very expensive. And do I need 10G really? I do not think so. I did calculated few things when I was thinking about 10G and most probably I will not saturate 1G for few years. And with phones ans laptops mostly WiFi is used anyways.

                                                                        So can I ask you what is the advantage for using 10G equipment in your case? Even something really dull like network card costs around 100€.

                                                                        • zdp7 3 months ago
                                                                          You don't need an expensive switch. Five port 2.5G + SFP+ with poe can be pretty affordable and shouldn't run very hot.
                                                                          • delamon 3 months ago
                                                                            XikeStor SKS8300-8X costs about 100$, can do L3 routing, has 8 10G SFP+ ports, no fan and consumes ~9W. I'm running it in my homelab without any issues.
                                                                          • bloomingeek 3 months ago
                                                                            Friendly reminder: newer modem, router (especially for wireless), cat cable and fast speed switches really make a difference. I had the fastest speed my ISP could provide, but then discovered I needed to upgrade some of my equipment. It made all the difference in the world, especially cat 6e cable.
                                                                          • sponaugle 3 months ago
                                                                            "(running fibre in the house isn't practical yet)"

                                                                            What does that mean? I assume you are saying most builders don't offer fiber?

                                                                            Running fiber in a house is entirely practical and easy to do. Cheap as well.

                                                                            • chgs 3 months ago
                                                                              Might as well, but most end devices you’d want to connect would be copper. Most devices I physically connect are poe anyway. Sure my nas and desktop are fibre/10g, but my aps are all Poe copper, my laptop is copper unless I break out my dongle (although it’s rare ok not on wifi), my backup pihole is copper (I like having a second dns server in case the main vm on the nas fails)
                                                                            • sponaugle 3 months ago
                                                                              These are great and common regrets in house wiring. I'm actually recording a video series on this exact topic right now. There are some things in electrical that are so easy and cheap to do but just get skipped over. Electricians are typically very very cheap (in a good for you the consumer way). However this tends to lead to under-building in a modern tech house.
                                                                              • jmacd 3 months ago
                                                                                Wow, we recently built a house and this reads just like my regret list!

                                                                                I think because there are less code specifications for the garage, builders just don't bother.

                                                                                • cryptoegorophy 3 months ago
                                                                                  Why 4 ethernet ports? You can just add switch later if that is the problem. I have this setup behind TV for Apple TV+TV
                                                                                  • mmastrac 3 months ago
                                                                                    If you have any way to pull cables between floors, try pulling DAC cables. They give you 10+G, require no splicing (hardware can be found cheap now), and generally just work as you'd expect.

                                                                                    With a 10G backbone, you can get away with basement->main and main->upstairs in a three-floor house, with a small bridge on your main floor.

                                                                                    • ianburrell 3 months ago
                                                                                      There is no reason to pull DAC when fiber has gotten cheap. Singlemode fiber is cheap enough now that isn't worth doing multimode fiber. You can get pre-terminated fiber that is easier to pulling whole DAC transceiver.

                                                                                      DAC is still useful for within rack.

                                                                                      • mmastrac 3 months ago
                                                                                        True, though what I like about DAC is that there's far less risk of optical surface damage.

                                                                                        Sure there's ESD risk but I find that much easier to manage.

                                                                                      • bhouston 3 months ago
                                                                                        > If you have any way to pull cables between floors, try pulling DAC cables.

                                                                                        Many of my devices take 10G ethernet, like MacMini and my MacBook Air docking station. Is there an easy way to convert from DAC to 10G Ethernet? The desktop has an SPF+ card so that will take DAC no problem.

                                                                                        Unfortunately there is no way to pull an any cables easily. But someone else suggested replaceable baseboards that hide cable runs, I should look into that.

                                                                                      • Epa095 3 months ago
                                                                                        Why DAC cables over Cat6a or Cat7
                                                                                        • graton 3 months ago
                                                                                          They are the lowest power way to connect SFP. And they are cheap.

                                                                                          Though I'm not sure I would pull them as they tend to max out at around 6-7 meters. I use them to connect systems within the same rack/room.

                                                                                          • bhouston 3 months ago
                                                                                            10G Ethernet seems to be really hot, all my SPF+ connectors are hot, my TP-Link 10G switch is hot. It seems not be efficient anymore in that regards.

                                                                                            While my 10G fiber and 10G SPF+ DAC cables are perfectly cool.

                                                                                            I hope this is temporary but 10G Ethernet seems hot. I haven't seen anyone write on this topic yet but it is my findings.

                                                                                        • lostlogin 3 months ago
                                                                                          > running fibre in the house isn't practical yet

                                                                                          I think it is. A pair of switches and a single run isn’t that expensive and it’s truly beautiful.

                                                                                          But… I still wish I’d put in 2 cables and not one.

                                                                                          • yjftsjthsd-h 3 months ago
                                                                                            > Only a single ethernet port in the basement. Then the kid wanted a gaming station and we moved where the TV was. I should have put like 4 down there.

                                                                                            Is it so bad to put in a switch?

                                                                                            • bhouston 3 months ago
                                                                                              It does sort of suck because I have cabling running along the baseboards. Also I have 10G networking so the switches are costly and hot at least this generation.
                                                                                              • LgWoodenBadger 3 months ago
                                                                                                How would multiple runs have helped you with that problem? Either they’re all in the same spot, and a switch would solve it, or they’re on all different walls and you’d still likely have to run cables to the things.
                                                                                          • timzaman 3 months ago
                                                                                            1. High-level, the post is all wrong. The point should be that you always need to make sure you can pull new cable. The poster illustrates this: single mode, multi mode, non-fiber, etc, etc. And if one "goes bad", you still can't run a new one, unless you have a pullstring.

                                                                                            2. The post cannot apply to fast/large networks - will be prohibitively expensive.

                                                                                            3. If running a few at home, I suggest to run MTP/MPO. It's basically a structured cable that can have around 12 fibers in them, plenty of future expansion.

                                                                                            Though I'll always run a large awg >>cat6 everywhere so it supports PoE++

                                                                                            • stronglikedan 3 months ago
                                                                                              > And if one "goes bad", you still can't run a new one, unless you have a pullstring.

                                                                                              The one that went bad is the pullstring.

                                                                                              • avidiax 3 months ago
                                                                                                > The one that went bad is the pullstring.

                                                                                                That works for short runs, but for long runs, the only way to pull the cable without breaking it is to use wire pulling lubricant.

                                                                                                And there's no guarantee that the cable you are pulling is undamaged. Rats don't improve pull strength, and even an electrically good cable can have the tensile strength cord severed.

                                                                                                If you are in that situation, pulling the old cable with dried lube on it may snap it in two, especially if it's pulling the new strand.

                                                                                                That's why leaving a pulling tape in each conduit is a good idea.

                                                                                                • sponaugle 3 months ago
                                                                                                  This is correct - I have pull strings in my conduits at my house for that reason. Pulling fiber down my 1000ft driveway would be difficult to do if the pull string was another fiber.

                                                                                                  You can pull a new pull string in empty conduit pretty easily with a shop vac and a ziploc bag.

                                                                                              • throwaway2037 3 months ago

                                                                                                    > If running a few at home, I suggest to run ... that can have around 12 fibers in them, plenty of future expansion.
                                                                                                
                                                                                                What kind of home network needs 12 fibers on a single run!?
                                                                                                • sponaugle 3 months ago
                                                                                                  I ran fiber when I built my house a few years ago. I have MANY 12 fiber runs going to my IDF/MDFs, Server room, the gate, the dmarc, etc. I also ran SM fiber to every AP location. Out of 20 miles of pulls about 1 mile was fiber.
                                                                                                  • delamon 3 months ago
                                                                                                    Why not copper with PoE to the APs? You still have to get power to AP somehow.
                                                                                                  • WorkerBee28474 3 months ago
                                                                                                    Tautologically, a high-bandwidth one.
                                                                                                  • mschuster91 3 months ago
                                                                                                    > 3. If running a few at home, I suggest to run MTP/MPO. It's basically a structured cable that can have around 12 fibers in them, plenty of future expansion.

                                                                                                    For a homelab honestly just pull pre-terminated cable with LC connectors, a 20 or 25mm hollow pipe is enough. That way you don't need a splicer machine, experience on how to operate it, or measuring equipment.

                                                                                                    • bananapub 3 months ago
                                                                                                      what a bizarre reply.

                                                                                                      the author is a sysadmin, who can definitely change what is plugged in to the switches their employer has chosen to buy, but doesn't have the power to make physical changes between multiple buildings, easily authorise opex spending on cable pullers or retrain as a cable puller.

                                                                                                      please actually consider what you're replying to before pushing the REPLY button.

                                                                                                      • dsr_ 3 months ago
                                                                                                        > 2. The post cannot apply to fast/large networks - will be prohibitively expensive.

                                                                                                        The expensive parts of fast/large networks are not the fiber strands.

                                                                                                        * right of use / lease

                                                                                                        * trenching and laying and covering

                                                                                                        * amplifiers on long lines

                                                                                                        * repair/maintenance

                                                                                                        * endpoints

                                                                                                        ... which is why the first thing you upgrade are the endpoints, and the last you do is lay more fiber. Get the most you can afford (often physically) at the beginning.

                                                                                                        • hinkley 3 months ago
                                                                                                          Pull strings don’t give you a way to pull new cables. They give you a backup way to pull new cables. Every cable in a conduit can be used to pull its own replacement or 2. But if anything goes wrong, you have a second chance before you have to go find the fishing rod.
                                                                                                          • liotier 3 months ago
                                                                                                            > 2. The post cannot apply to fast/large networks - will be prohibitively expensive.

                                                                                                            Yes, it is obviously about small-scale sysadmin cabling. Telco networks have wildly different economics.

                                                                                                            • 3 months ago
                                                                                                            • runjake 3 months ago
                                                                                                              If you have the choice, always run single-mode. It’s infinitely more scalable than multimode and the price is on-par. Around here, SMF is currently cheaper.

                                                                                                              SMF optics are single digit dollars more expensive than MMF optics, if you use third-party modules. And you might as well use them because your SP does. In my experience they’re better built and more reliable (longer lasting and lower failure rate. n=1000s of modules) than first-party Cisco optics.

                                                                                                              • traceroute66 3 months ago
                                                                                                                > In my experience they’re better built and more reliable (longer lasting and lower failure rate. n=1000s of modules) than first-party Cisco optics

                                                                                                                And for the typical price of a Cisco optic you can buy two third-party optics. So now you have a spare. :)

                                                                                                                • runjake 3 months ago
                                                                                                                  From the last quote I got, I could buy almost 10 third-party Fs.com optics for the price of a Cisco OEM optic ($2,500 vs $250). And the FS.com seem to be manufactured more durably. And have a lower failure rate.
                                                                                                                  • traceroute66 3 months ago
                                                                                                                    Personally I prefer Flexoptix for two reasons.

                                                                                                                    First, they are reprogrammable. They will send you a free programming box with your first order if you agree to a public testimonial on their website. Support are also very responsive if you need new codings they'll try to work with you to find something that works (they can push new codes to your coding box).

                                                                                                                    Second, more recently, they have the option to choose "not made in China". They sell both China and what they call "S2 Origin" which is any of Germany, Thailand, Taiwan, Vietnam and Malaysia.

                                                                                                                    Only downside is if you are buying for personal use you won't be able to buy from Flexoptics. They only sell to companies. (They do have a small number of resellers though, so you might have more luck with indirect sourcing for personal purchases ... you won't get a free programming box tough).

                                                                                                                • runjake 3 months ago
                                                                                                                  An addendum here that architectural firms and builders will still often spec out MMF for in-building fiber. You want to tell them "No, use SMF instead".

                                                                                                                  They will look at you funny and maybe even tell you "that's more expensive" because they haven't looked at price lists in over a decade. But they are wrong on all counts (unless you exist in a really whacky market). The only exception here is that some video, HVAC, etc systems require MMF to stay in warranty. In those cases, run both and use the MMF only for that junk.

                                                                                                                • JoshTriplett 3 months ago
                                                                                                                  No mention in the article of making sure to run conduit, so you can always add more cables easily.
                                                                                                                  • jedberg 3 months ago
                                                                                                                    It should mention conduit for sure, but sometimes conduit is hard if you want to stick to the rule of no more than 180 degrees of bend in the line (and no more than 90 at one bend). Long conduit runs need junction boxes at some of of the bends, and it's hard to always make those accessible.
                                                                                                                    • dnemmers 3 months ago
                                                                                                                      I thought you were allowed 4 90 degree bends, or 360 degrees between boxes.
                                                                                                                      • jedberg 3 months ago
                                                                                                                        Code allows up to 360 degrees, but it gets really hard to pull after 180.
                                                                                                                    • quickthrowman 3 months ago
                                                                                                                      Well, conduit plus multi-cell innerduct to make it easy.
                                                                                                                      • JoshTriplett 3 months ago
                                                                                                                        First I've heard of this! What's the advantage, in your experience?
                                                                                                                    • paulkon 3 months ago
                                                                                                                      This right here is important. We could be running fiber end to end in the near future. Ethernet would end up obsolete like the phone line.
                                                                                                                      • fach 3 months ago
                                                                                                                        How would running fiber make Ethernet obsolete? Physical medium and framing on the wire are fairly orthogonal.
                                                                                                                        • JoshTriplett 3 months ago
                                                                                                                          People commonly use the word "Ethernet" to mean "Ethernet cable", as in a copper cable with an RJ45 on it, not just "Ethernet protocol", which is used over both copper and fiber alike.
                                                                                                                    • protocolture 3 months ago
                                                                                                                      I recall working in a building that:

                                                                                                                      1. Was the former HQ for a local telecom company 2. Was now an office building with a couple floors of data.

                                                                                                                      Ages ago, one of the DC providers in the building had run 36 cores to the roof to service a telco.

                                                                                                                      It was a massive undertaking, the building is riddled with asbestos and old plant. Had multiple renovations etc.

                                                                                                                      Anyway, a few years later, every telco in the state wanted to be on that rooftop. And they had the only reliable means to service it with fibre. That 36 core became a massive profit generating asset, one that they could have monetised even further if they had have run 100 core instead. But it was never feasible to drill holes for a new duct (Asbestos regulations getting tighter), and it was never feasible to shut down 12 telcos for a day to use the existing fibre as a draw cable.

                                                                                                                      Getting a single core rented here, and throwing on Bidi's, was like mana from the gods at the time.

                                                                                                                      • jmacd 3 months ago
                                                                                                                        I just had this experience. I had a 200ft run between my house and barn. The original builder put a direct bury ethernet between the two and it failed. I dug a trench, put in a conduit, pulled 2 fibre lines and left a pull string in.

                                                                                                                        I recently had the primary fibre fail and am now on the backup. If I need to pull new ones in the future I can do that pretty easily through the conduit.

                                                                                                                        • bityard 3 months ago
                                                                                                                          Yep. Direct-burial ethernet is surprisingly vulnerable to nearby lightning strikes. It's not a matter of IF the cable or devices get damaged, it's a matter of when. Nearby (not even direct) lightning induces ground voltage potentials between buildings to the tune of hundreds of volts or more.
                                                                                                                          • c0nsumer 3 months ago
                                                                                                                            Do you have experience or information on direct burial ethernet for something like a POE camera? I'd like to put one on the back fence to watch the back of the house and yard. Direct burial in the back yard would be a plenty easy thing to do, but the cable is pricey enough that I've held off for now.
                                                                                                                            • LgWoodenBadger 3 months ago
                                                                                                                              Whatever you do make sure you put a fiber media converter between the “ethernet” cable and your network to prevent your entire network getting fried.
                                                                                                                          • protocolture 3 months ago
                                                                                                                            I used to consult for an ISP that put direct bury in a region where it snows 1/3rd of the year.

                                                                                                                            It was profit generating. They would offer to put conduit in for an extra fee, the customers always said no, then they would be back to install conduit and cable in the spring after the ice had killed the cable.

                                                                                                                            • throwaway2037 3 months ago

                                                                                                                                  > I recently had the primary fibre fail
                                                                                                                              
                                                                                                                              Woah, this is surprising. Do you know the root cause? I could imagine copper cabling is much more sensitive to the outdoors, that is why I am so surprised about your fibre failure.
                                                                                                                            • chaz6 3 months ago
                                                                                                                              My business is fiber broadband, and we are laying as much as we can! Fortunately the legislative environment in the UK is conducive to this goal. For now we provide XGS PON (10Gbs minus overhead), with 50G PON becoming available in some locations later this year. Unlike regular point-to-point, it is point-to-multipoint through the use of optical splitters with one head-end port capable of servicing up to 256 clients. With the UK being so far behind most other developed countries, it means it can take advances in all of the R&D from the last twenty years. It has also led to the strange situation where there are some properties that have a choice between 4 or even more fibre network providers. Some fiber networks are tied to a single ISP whereas others are open to wholesale. I am not sure if there are any ISP's that support multiple connections to the same property via different fiber networks - but I think you would generally want to use a different ISP for each network anyway. IPv6 is supposed to make that easier, though in practice there are still no protocols (a la MEF 17 Service OAM) for the ONT to signal to the router that there is a fault condition. This is one circumstance where PPPoE is useful. As the UK has been slow to deploy fiber there are many ISPs still using it. I found this out the hard way when I made the switch. My trusty old Ubiquiti Edgerouter Lite (Cavium silicon) is not capable of hardware offload for ipv6+pppoe+vlan at the same time, so anything particularly demanding on IPv6 (e.g. Steam) essentially locks up the router. I will be trying out an Alta Labs Route10 this week to see if it provides any improvement.
                                                                                                                              • ggm 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                Not as a serious other-side but I knew an engineer associated with ARUP and during the time of Canary Wharf being in design, the plenum spaces were re-sized twice as a function of emerging pre-fibre burdens.

                                                                                                                                I believe now, there is probably the equivalent of 3 or more floors of unused space, consumed by oversize plenum in the light of emerging fibre.

                                                                                                                                I do believe fibre probably is a sensible end road for "small enough" and so pulling more of it, for the same radial bend and cable diameter probably makes sense.

                                                                                                                                Also bear in mind "re clocking" by tuning the lambdas and deploying new lasers is a thing. That 100 pair fibre can be re-clocked across it's lifetime and be the equivalent of 1000 pairs in equivalent bandwidth, by the time you're done.

                                                                                                                                • interroboink 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                  “We’re only going to do this once and there’s always the unforeseen.”

                                                                                                                                  — Joseph Bazalgette, on doubling the pipe diameter when building the London sewer system

                                                                                                                                  (though I don't have an original source for that quote)

                                                                                                                                  • eemil 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                    I'm surprised Chris left out a big reason: cable is cheap, and labor is expensive. And there are a lot of fixed costs that don't depend on the number of cables or their thickness.

                                                                                                                                    You might save a little bit going with 4 pairs instead of 24. But that goes out the window as soon as you need to run a single new cable. If you want to be stingy, pull the cables but leave them unterminated.

                                                                                                                                    • zelon88 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                      We've almost come full circle with the idea of "run more cabling" already in some ways.

                                                                                                                                      For example, a building built in 1960 had analog phone lines. Then in the 80s network lines were added. Then in the 90s - 00s more and more and more network were added.

                                                                                                                                      Then in the 2010-2020's we're starting to wind back down. Removing switches and racks that used to be fully populated with CAT5 which are now mostly empty. The end devices that needed these runs are now running on WiFi.

                                                                                                                                      • zelon88 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                        To elaborate a little bit;

                                                                                                                                        I've been in many, many buildings for cabling issues. While I generally agree with your assessment of "run more everything" I think this could be taken out of hand for a lot of smaller IT departments who aren't capable of using more advanced methods of network building. Like subnetting, VLAN trunking, or redundant links.

                                                                                                                                        Why would you need to learn about these things if you've got 3 or 4 more pairs of fiber hanging down? Then you have a situation that I've seen before, where you have 2 fiber runs carrying flat networks right next to each other with just a couple of IP phones on each one.

                                                                                                                                      • js2 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                        > Some of the time this fiber failure is (probably) because a raccoon got into your machine room

                                                                                                                                        Or into your handhole/vault, along with her babies:

                                                                                                                                        https://old.reddit.com/r/FiberOptics/comments/1ji3rrt/its_no...

                                                                                                                                        • aftbit 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                          Regarding single mode vs multi-mode ... other than cost, is there any reason at all to run multi-mode fiber in 2025? I was under the impression that single mode was better in basically every way.
                                                                                                                                          • fleventynine 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                            Multi-mode transceivers used to be a lot cheaper than single mode, but now they're around the same price for short distances. From what I can tell, most datacenters appear to be making the switch to single mode even for in-room networking.
                                                                                                                                            • FredFS456 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                              Multimode transceivers are still a slight bit cheaper ($30 for 10GBASE-LR vs $22 for 10GBASE-SR on fs.com) but that's more than offset by the single mode fiber being slightly cheaper, even for short distances.
                                                                                                                                            • hinkley 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                              Why does multi mode sound like it should carry more bandwidth but from context seems to be the less interesting option?
                                                                                                                                              • damnitpeter 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                Mode is simply the wavepattern of the light traveling through the optical fiber. Multimode means there are a few different wavepatterns traveling down the fiber, they tend to potentially interfere and its not as efficient of a use of optical power. In singlemode, this is a lot harder to do and requires better optics, the light is in one pattern, power is efficiently allocated to that pattern, and thus the light can be sent much further. Its been many years since college so hopefully that explanation suffices.

                                                                                                                                                Now lets say you want to send multiple signals to get more bandwidth on one fiber, you just need to move the frequency/wavelength of light so different signals have different wavelengths and can be discerned at the receiving end. That's gonna take even more optics and filters on both ends, but works quite well to add more bandwidth to existing fiber installations where running more fiber would cost a lot more than installing new equipment on the ends.

                                                                                                                                              • FuriouslyAdrift 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                It's DAC in rack and then fiber or copper between spine and leaf (depends on distance, etc).
                                                                                                                                              • thefz 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                Cost, and marginally, heat of the transceivers.
                                                                                                                                                • throwaway2037 3 months ago

                                                                                                                                                      > heat of the transceivers
                                                                                                                                                  
                                                                                                                                                  I never heard this before, but I have no reason to doubt you. Are multi-mode or single-mode transceivers hotter, and why?
                                                                                                                                                  • thefz 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                    Single mode uses more power because the light emitter is more powerful, usually
                                                                                                                                                • DanAtC 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                  No. Just run single mode.
                                                                                                                                                • j45 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                  Originally thought this was excessive, but at least 4 per outlet/room. Saves buying a bunch of smaller switches.

                                                                                                                                                  1 for a switch (Although VLans can help) 1 for telephony if required 1 for media devices / peripherals 1 extra

                                                                                                                                                  Optional fun use of HDMI over ethernet for more runs.

                                                                                                                                                  Behind TVs, you can break it down, or just run a bunch of runs.

                                                                                                                                                  • hinkley 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                    I routinely wish someone had designed a power outlet shaped switch that runs on POE.

                                                                                                                                                    But some brands would run too hot for an enclosed space and a Netgear one would burn your fucking house down.

                                                                                                                                                    • lotharrr 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                      I've been pretty happy with Unifi's "In-Wall" AP (e.g. https://store.ui.com/us/en/category/wifi-wall/products/u6-iw): PoE powered, has four downstream RJ45 ports (one with PoE itself), and is a side-firing WiFi AP as well. Like the sibling comment said, they're made for hotel rooms, but I've never been in a hotel fancy enough to use them (possibly because the RJ45 sockets aren't particularly discoverable, being on the bottom). It doesn't live in a power outlet, but it's meant to be mounted at the same height. Worked great for my home office. (I'm not associated with Unifi, just happy with their gear)
                                                                                                                                                      • hinkley 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                        Yeah surface mounts aren't bad. Combined switch and Wifi is good.

                                                                                                                                                        Seems like for discoverability you'd have to mount it backward or upside down somewhere so that people can see the ports, and then what about the wifi signal? I see what you mean.

                                                                                                                                                      • toast0 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                        I've seen some 'in-wall' access points that might be kind of what you're looking for. Designed for hotels, etc, they have an ethernet port on the back with poe-in, and usually two ethernet ports on the front, and also do wifi.

                                                                                                                                                        I have no experience with them, though.

                                                                                                                                                        • hinkley 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                          There are modular jacks that can expose 6 or 8 different connectors on one outlet. I just figured the hotel ones were a slightly more sophisticated version of that.
                                                                                                                                                        • j45 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                          There are some depending on the number of ports you're after. I'm not sure if it would run directly on Poe, but maybe PoE could be converted to USB power to run something like a GL-iNET device or something that sized.

                                                                                                                                                          https://www.gl-inet.com/products/gl-b3000/

                                                                                                                                                          A bigger issue with ethernet presently and for the last while is unreasonable prices on 10GbE both adapters, switches, etc.

                                                                                                                                                          Sticking with other mediums for now for 10GbE

                                                                                                                                                      • sponaugle 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                        In a home buildout, running fiber is surprisingly inexpensive and easy to do. There is one area to watch out for - In most US homes drywall is installed with screws that go into studs so if you have large bundles of wire or fiber be careful how the sit relative to the surface of the studs. Often the drywall screws will be off by a bit an miss the stud. If you wire bundle is large enough and it is a 2x4 wall vs a 2x6 wall you can lose a number of wires with a puncture.

                                                                                                                                                        A second common problem is the wire installer pulling the fiber around sharp corners, sometimes with staples and zip ties. Fiber is surprisingly resilient, but very sharp bends will cause significant problems. Using armored fiber can help this a bit.

                                                                                                                                                        • traceroute66 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                          > Using armored fiber can help this a bit

                                                                                                                                                          You can also get bend-resilient unarmored fibre. Its what the incumbent telcos use when they send out their monkeys (sorry "engineers") who've been on a 4-hour afternoon course on how to install fibre before being let loose. Old copper "that'll do" install habits die hard in the telco world.

                                                                                                                                                          • myself248 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                            Nail plates.

                                                                                                                                                            Screws should _never_ be able to hit the wiring. If that's possible, someone failed to install nail plates or Smarshield sleeves.

                                                                                                                                                            As for the sharp corners, IMHO you should always install a raceway of some sort (everyone just uses smurf tube), then pull the fiber in afterward. It takes real effort to fuck up the bend radius of conduit.

                                                                                                                                                            • sponaugle 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                              I was not referring to wiring going thru studs, but along studs. Nail plates are very effective for going thru studs, but often wire is ran along the side of a stud. If it is a large bundle and you don't keep it centered on the side of the stud it will be close to the surface right where a screw could miss. Of course putting some kind of shielding or sleeve could work, but that is very uncommon in house building.

                                                                                                                                                              Smurf tubes work great, but are not practical in some high density environments, especially a house with steel structure and I-beam joists. I used these for some locations in my house, but not all.

                                                                                                                                                          • yetihehe 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                            I left one small room in my new home without network cabling, finished just before covid. Guess where my home office ended up being located...
                                                                                                                                                          • hadlock 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                            King County (Seattle) did this when wiring up the municipal network. Networking World ran at least two cover stories on this in the mid-1990s. They ran 200 ... bundles? Strands? Everywhere. That fiber is still there, under sidewalks, inside bridge structures, everywhere. Whoever bought the rights to that excess fiber from the city is probably subletting it to various FAANG and datacenters making a small fortune. That fiber runs through most of downtown seattle.
                                                                                                                                                            • eqvinox 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                              > Fiber comes in two varieties, single mode and multi-mode. I don't know enough to know if you should make a point of running both[…]

                                                                                                                                                              Let me fill this in: in 2025 you (and everybody else) should be running SMF. If you need to directly connect to existing MMF you should run that additionally. But do not build MMF-only in 2025. It's akin to installing Cat5 (non-E) or even Cat3. And you pay mostly for the work, not the cable. Do yourself a favour and put SMF in.

                                                                                                                                                              • FuriouslyAdrift 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                Agreed. SMF can handle nearly anything. A single strand can handle 100Gb 10km for OS1 or 100km for OS2 per frequency and you can do multiple frequencies at the same time or go bidirectional, too.
                                                                                                                                                              • cheema33 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                I subscribe to this philosophy.

                                                                                                                                                                I recently had my house remodeled. A lot of the walls were opened up and I asked the contractor to run fiber and cat 6a everywhere. Now every room has multiple drops of each. Even the outdoor and garage have several drops. Bathrooms have ethernet. Attic, basement and storage room has multiple drops. I may have overdone it. But, I never wanted to every worry about this ever again.

                                                                                                                                                                • joshuaheard 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                  I thought about multiple drops of cat6 per room in my house, but they charged me per drop. So I just put one drop in each room and added a switch in a room that needs multiple connections. It's usually for Wifi WAP, smart TV, and the Tivo box.
                                                                                                                                                                  • throwaway2037 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                    Nice story. Why did you choose to drop both fiber and copper? My assumption: You can run 1/2.5G very cheap these days over copper. When 10G/25G gets much cheaper later, you can switch to fiber.
                                                                                                                                                                    • sponaugle 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                      There is no power over fiber.
                                                                                                                                                                  • thefz 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                    I was under the impression that once laid, fiber is the most stable and future proof between all mediums (barring physical damage). After all it won't rot, stain or degrade like copper. It's plastic, mostly.
                                                                                                                                                                    • protocolture 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                      Depends on timescale.

                                                                                                                                                                      Like if you are in an area that has frequent natural disasters or just heaps of construction work, you will find that RF is more stable and future proof.

                                                                                                                                                                      Also, you can get issues with cable bends and terminations. Which are simple to fix, but often go undetected by cheap fiber carriers.

                                                                                                                                                                      I manage a couple pair of dark fibre for a customer, and the fibre runs through a couple of suburbs that are under constant development. And they have near monthly half day outages, and quarterly 1 - 2 day fibre outages.

                                                                                                                                                                      Like others have said, backhoes hunger for the glass.

                                                                                                                                                                      • eqvinox 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                        It is, it's just not immune to physical damage. Rodents and Jackhammers…
                                                                                                                                                                        • FuriouslyAdrift 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                          Backhoes can find fiber from miles away... they hunger for it
                                                                                                                                                                      • Taniwha 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                        And if you can't, always pull a string through the conduit .....
                                                                                                                                                                        • arghwhat 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                          Just always pull a string through the conduit, full stop.
                                                                                                                                                                        • jonhohle 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                          As the article says, this is true for just about any cabling, copper, power, etc.

                                                                                                                                                                          I’ve done cabling in two houses and I’ve never had too much. I’m always finding reasons to run more to new places.

                                                                                                                                                                          • 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                          • em3rgent0rdr 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                            Had a squirrel chew through the fiber internet cable going to our basement. Fortunately there was enough slack that the unchewed cable could still be pulled and reach the telephone pole and reconnect without having to redig the entire path, which would have cost much more.
                                                                                                                                                                            • DeathArrow 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                              At home I have a pair of single mode fiber running in each room, it is future proof enough for me.

                                                                                                                                                                              ATM running at 1Gbps, but I will soon upgrade the router, switches, SFP+ modules to run at 10Gbps since my internet provider will upgrade the offering from 2.3 Gbps to 10 Gbps this year.

                                                                                                                                                                              • olalonde 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                                YAGNI: You Are Gonna Need It.
                                                                                                                                                                                • VoodooJuJu 3 months ago
                                                                                                                                                                                  [dead]