I got a remote job for a EU company, I'd find it hard to go back to a US-based

58 points by nixass 1 month ago | 83 comments
  • austin-cheney 1 month ago
    I have had a federal security clearance since I was a teenager and most of that time it’s been a top secret clearance. Yet, I never worked as a government contractor until my current employment. Huge mistake.

    It’s so much better than the corporate world even as a software developer and even with all the draconian security restrictions. Actually, the restrictions are nearly identical to working at a major bank. The primary reason it’s so much better is the people. The people tend to skew much older with far more experience, they tend to be better educated, and they all must have clearances and IT certifications. That eliminates so much of the entitlement, insecurity, and general stupidity I saw in my peers as a 15 year corporate software developer.

    • jcadam 1 month ago
      I worked in defense contracting for most of my ~20 year career up until a few months ago. So I'm experiencing this culture shock the other way around. Being the oldest person on a team is... strange.

      Still have my clearance for a couple years I suppose - perhaps all this anti-remote madness will be over before then.

      • glimshe 1 month ago
        How do you solve the catch-22 of security clearance? It seems that a lot of jobs require it but not so many people want to pay for me to get it. Is it possible to get clearance by myself on the side (assume I'm willing to deal with the fees and paperwork)?
        • austin-cheney 1 month ago
          No. You must have a sponsor that pays for the clearance. The government officially claims that a secret clearance costs around $3000 and a top secret costs around $15000. That does not include the actual investigation of sending people into the field to perform interviews. The actual costs can be well into 6 figures. You don't want to pay for that.

          If you have critical skills then a large contractor like Raytheon or McDonnelL Douglas will gladly pay for it. The cost of the clearance is absolutely worth it to fill a position that drives a project forward.

      • mcntsh 1 month ago
        I've worked for major US companies in the Bay Area/NYC and German companies here in Europe so I feel like I can weigh in here.

        In Germany I make way less, it's true, but I have a much higher quality of life and feeling of security here and I'd never willfully move back to the US. There's more to life than money, as they say...

        • nicbou 1 month ago
          I run a website about migrating to Germany. I have to teol people that they should take sick days when they're sick, and that they should not even look at their emails when they're on vacation. It's not just laws, but a culture that backs them up.

          A favourite fact of mine is that if you're sick when on vacation, you get your vacation days back.

          • mcntsh 1 month ago
            My favorite is the right to go to part time work after 6 months. People don't realize the 4 day work week already exists in Germany if you want it.
            • stuaxo 1 month ago
              Sure, though the 4 day week is really taking the same amount of pay as you would for 5 days, so it's not the same.
            • cardanome 1 month ago
              I mean there are still toxic companies in Germany as well. There are people who are too scared to take their sick days.

              Worker's rights are vastly better in Germany than the US but that is a very low bar to set.

              If you work at at a company with strong union presence and Betriebsrat, yes, you will have a good life. That is not the reality for most people though. If you work for a smaller company in some low skilled job, your life will be vastly different.

              Social security and worker's right have constantly been attacked politically in the last decades and are chipped away piece by piece. The public health care system has be systematically and purposely weakened to the point that it is close to collapse.

              Germany is still one of the better countries to live and work in but not as great as it used to be. But that is true for most countries thanks to the rise of neoliberalism.

              • robocat 1 month ago
                > Social security and worker's right have constantly been attacked politically in the last decades and are chipped away piece by piece. The public health care system has be systematically and purposely weakened

                Political off-topic:

                That is happening in New Zealand too, but the question is, what is the underlying cause?

                Is it because New Zealand is slowly going broke: failure to increase export earnings due to business owners incentives, structural issues with NZ economy, whatever?

                Is it because capitalism keeps taking more and workers get less?

                Is it because NZ society is mimicking American business selfish „ethics“?

                On reflection, I don't think it is politics nor capitalism . . . I believe it is due to demographics here: it appears that New Zealand cannot afford the expectations set in the past for healthcare and superannuation and worker's rights. Smart capable young NZers emmigrate (mostly to Australia but diaspora to everywhere).

                It is natural to want to blame the political system, but I believe that demographics cause the same economic pressures, regardless of politics. There needs to be enough workers to tax to pay for the people not working (retirees, sick, unemployed). It is better to think of in terms of hours worked rather than money (same hours are required regardless of political system).

                I visited Cuba and investigated for myself the gap between truth and propoganda. NZ is doing vastly better with capitalism (capitalism causes serious problems, but authoritarian lefty countries have far worse unescapable problems for individuals).

                Note that the NZ "right" government is still very "left" compared with say the US. Also note that apparently the current US policy is "PROTECT SOCIAL SECURITY AND MEDICARE WITH NO CUTS, INCLUDING NO CHANGES TO THE RETIREMENT AGE" - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44210019

                Disclosure: I'm a white welloff software WEIRDo dude, but I give careful attention to the problems of others (working-class peers, poorly retirees). I predict future struggles for myself even though I'm well off - and the median person will have it much harder than I.

                * aside:: tried to do 66 99 „quotes” but can't get the closing to to look like 99s on iPhone

            • wenc 1 month ago
              I've never worked in Germany, but I worked for the U.S. branch of a German multinational company, reported to a German manager and visited Germany a couple of times.

              Living in Germany felt like it wasn't for me. There is very little diversity in ethnic foods (doner kebaps and Italian was about as ethnic as it got, outside of a sprinkling of Chinese restaurants), and everything felt really old (in a conservative way -- not in an artistic way like in Paris). Foodies would struggle with Germany (great breads, sausages, pork, and beer but nothing else stands out).

              German management was also not for me -- it felt really old-fashioned compared to American management, and it was hard to do anything new -- there were a lot of gatekeepers where it was their way or the highway. Ideas would get discussed and blocked at every turn, and there were lots of rigid egos.

              The U-Bahn/S-Bahn/ICE train systems there were good (undoubtedly, better than anything in America), but compared to Asia or other parts of Europe, they felt a bit old and not really that punctual. The whole place just lacked dynamism.

              It's ironic because I've admired Germany all my life. This is, after all, the land of Gauss, Bach, Goethe, Beethoven, etc. It's the land of great physicists and chemists.

              Yet there is a sense that what was once great about Germany (all the great thinkers, high tech, etc.) is not really at the forefront anymore. Instead, I saw a nation resting on its laurels, and accepting too much bureaucracy in many aspects of life.

              If I was into doing lifestyle optimization, I feel I'll find a decent, if unexciting, life in Germany where my basic needs are taken care of.

              But I feel if you really want to work on something new and exciting, that's not the place to be. (I was in Munich where the money is but people are conservative when it comes to new things. I heard Berlin is much more innovative but generally have no money to scale).

              • BrandoElFollito 1 month ago
                It of course depends on the company, area and vertical but yes, there is a lot of stiffness. German humour is not mainstream:)

                But every European country has its specificities - in France for instance you have an ungodly controlled chaos and draining bureaucracy (I am French).

                Having worked in many, many countries in the world, Europeans cities/companies are on the top for me, all taken into account.

              • xnx 1 month ago
                > I'd never willfully move back to the US

                Do you think there's benefit to working for an EU company from the US?

                • mcntsh 1 month ago
                  Culture. You probably don't have to take PTO for sick days, you probably get a lot of vacation days and won't get pressure not to take them, you probably won't get called past 5 o'clock or on weekends, etc.
                • jonmil 1 month ago
                  Any advice for an American in BigTech looking to move to Europe? I've been applying for EU jobs for awhile but that seems like a lottery
                  • BrandoElFollito 1 month ago
                    First choose your country. It will be much more difficult to get a job in France than in, say, Poland for an American (because of how the US is perceived)

                    Then you need to look at the company and see if they already have some US staff. Some do, some don't.

                    Finally you must have a very unique set of skills to be taken into consideration. We have plenty of excellent people in high tech.

                    Finally, but you know that already, you raw pay will take a huge cut.

                    • jonmil 1 month ago
                      Yeah that's what I was afraid of; the perception of the US (and US managers) is not great, which puts me at a disadvantage. There are a ton of very well-qualified people already in Europe, which really makes it very difficult to immigrate.

                      I was initially thinking that a startup might be the best bet, but it seems like very few of them provide sponsorships. The best bet is looking more like trying an internal transfer at my big-tech firm instead. Thanks for your insight!

                • newswasboring 1 month ago
                  I have worked for a european tech giant for over six years now. And when talking to my US friends, this is the biggest difference I have seen.

                  > In the US, it can often feel that your work is your identity. My European colleagues take pride in their work and are extremely hard workers, but their job is one facet of their identity.

                  In a non-office setting, I would sooner introduce myself as an improviser and bouldering enthusiast than an engineer. Although, I am the kind of person who codes to relax, not letting my job take over my identity is my last resistance in this boring dystopia.

                  edit: forgot a negation which totally changed the meaning of last sentence.

                  • NalNezumi 1 month ago
                    This difference is probably also why my brother who moved to US, and Now back to Europe (with his American wife) struggle with European colleagues.

                    They're both passionate about their work (game devs usually are) but feel like no one at their office share that sentiment. When it's 5Pm, even before deadline, people just leave. During breaks, they rather talk about local football teams than most recent news about their profession.

                    So that's the other side of the coin

                    • spacemadness 1 month ago
                      Leaving at 5pm seems entirely reasonable to a non workaholic. When is a reasonable time that you think people should leave to prove their worth I wonder. At some point it’s a performative race to the bottom. And yes I know the game industry loves to abuse peoples passion by demanding crunch and burning out young engineers for crap pay.
                  • supriyo-biswas 1 month ago
                    I'm not disputing the title per se as I have not worked for EU companies. Having said that, news articles of this sort usually interview a few people and then has the journalist draw a conclusion by way of storytelling.

                    However, this article seems like an ad for a single company, where they post a direct link to their careers section and even heap praise on the interview experience, which is unusual unless the person is specifically talking about their career to another prospective employer or to an otherwise "professional" audience.

                    • buran77 1 month ago
                      The points are generally applicable to any decent employer in the EU and most non-EU European countries, white collar work in particular. This is the norm not because companies are so much nicer. Most of this is codified in law. Some countries have better conditions than others. Minimum vacation period, paid overtime, the healthcare system, the public pension system, job security (protections from dismissal), employee representatives or union, etc. Your mileage may vary if you work remotely.

                      The obvious drawback is the difference in pay. European salaries are lower for the same job. Probably still lower even relative to real hours worked.

                      There's a less tangible and harder to quantify benefit of not having to deal with the same kind of job related stress a US worker has to deal with. The boost in quality of life that can't be gleaned from the size of your house or number of cars you own. So it's hard to factor that in when making a data driven comparison.

                    • ghusto 1 month ago
                      I couldn't my finger on this myself, but you nailed my feelings well.

                      Having said that, it doesn't make anything she's said inaccurate in itself, and I would even back up her take. I've worked for and with a few US companies, and ... jeeesh.

                      I feel the main cultural difference is that people here _presume_ you're doing your best, whereas in the USA people feel like they have to _prove_ they're doing their best.

                      • ericmay 1 month ago
                        That’s because it is an advertisement.
                        • paulcole 1 month ago
                          I love it when HR commenters discover PR.
                          • supriyo-biswas 1 month ago
                            The question then is why there's an advertorial on the front page? :)
                            • paulcole 1 month ago
                              HN is an advertising/marketing campaign run for a VC firm. You should assume nearly everything here is an ad of some kind in disguise.
                        • constantcrying 1 month ago
                          When will Americans realize that the EU is not a monolithic bloc? She worked for an Austrian company and benefited from Austrian laws and work culture.
                          • ACS_Solver 1 month ago
                            The EU is not a monolithic bloc, we have vast differences in overall culture, language, politics and more. Economy as well of course. To me, used to the northern parts, a place like Italy certainly feels foreign because so much is different. But employment laws are not as different as that.

                            Four weeks (20 days) of vacation is an EU-mandated minimum even if some countries give more. Parental leave varies a lot, but the EU minimum is 14 weeks of maternal and 2 weeks of paternal leave. The concept of "five sick days" or whatever other number doesn't exist in the EU, sick leave policy varies by member state but it's never limited to a few days. At-will employment likewise doesn't exist for normal jobs, there's no firing people on a whim because you don't like their work, and there's no place with less than a month's notice.

                            Healthcare is a bit different as it couldn't apply to a remote US worker, but still worth mentioning. The EU is very non-monolithic in the organization, quality and culture of healthcare, but each country has some kind of universal coverage model and so you cannot lose healthcare access by losing your job.

                            • messe 1 month ago
                              I would challenge you to find a country in the EU that has worse worker protections than the US, whether through statute or culture (for example norms about unionization).

                              I live in Denmark at the moment, and if my company wanted to lay me off without cause, they would have to give me three months notice. I have 6 weeks of vacation (with the option to take more unpaid; this 6 weeks is not including public holidays), private health insurance on top of the public health system through my company, pension both public and private, have no practical restrictions on sick leave, and work 37.5 hours a week (much of which can be done remotely). I have not once been asked to, or needed to work overtime, or be on-call unpaid. When I return home from work, unless I have planned to put a few remote hours in (to reduce my time spent at the office that week), I am neither expected nor required to answer emails or messages.

                              If I do lose my job, I will still receive a significant portion of my salary for a year, thanks to insurance through my union (I work as a software engineer).

                              • constantcrying 1 month ago
                                The working culture and laws between Bulgaria and Denmark are drastically different. It is absurd to talk about Denmark as if it were universal EU law. What you are experiencing is particular to Denmark. It is Danish law and work culture you are benefitting from.
                                • poisonborz 1 month ago
                                  EU laws are mostly scynchronized. Bulgaria has 1 month guaranteed minimum, IT companies typically give 3 as well.
                              • makeitdouble 1 month ago
                                It's not monolithic, but with freedom of movement inside its bound, it creates enough competition it's structurally harder to have any single country with really bad labor laws.
                                • ghusto 1 month ago
                                  Sure there are cultural differences between countries, but everything she said applies to all EU companies as far as my experience goes. Work life balance, work not being identity, holidays, etc. it's all applicable to every country in the EU I've worked in regardless of the local culture.
                                  • jxjnskkzxxhx 1 month ago
                                    When will Europeans realize that the USA is not a monolithic bloc?
                                    • 1 month ago
                                  • b3ing 1 month ago
                                    I had this same situation but if you are located in the US they will lay you off accordingly to US laws, which means it can happen anytime, but they will be nicer about it and maybe pay you a month to do nothing, on top of severance pay. The vacation time was high though.
                                    • stuaxo 1 month ago
                                      I worked in Glu Mobile when EA took them over.

                                      The US folks were all told to leave immediately.

                                      In the UK they had to give us notice and pay, also negotiate with employee representatives.

                                    • h1fra 1 month ago
                                      • farceSpherule 1 month ago
                                        Business Insider... What a rag of a publication...
                                        • creshal 1 month ago
                                          A German-owned rag, courtesy of Axel Springer SE, the continent's most famous yellow rag sweatshop
                                        • bloqs 1 month ago
                                          wonder what the pay difference is
                                          • ghusto 1 month ago
                                            When you find out, don't forget to factor in everything else she gets.

                                            The things your higher salary gets you can be had _right this instant_ if you took a different job with a (potentially) lower salary. Money doesn't make you feel good, the things money can _get_ you makes you feel good, and they are often free!

                                            • sokoloff 1 month ago
                                              She works in people ops, where I’d expect the US pay premium to be low or non-existent, at least as compared to tech.
                                              • poisonborz 1 month ago
                                                The whole point is that this doesn't matter, it's a much less important factor than US employees would assume.
                                                • HenryBemis 1 month ago
                                                  Wait till someone gets a serious disease (as it happens in many families) and lose their home, car, and their shirt because US healthcare is ....(crickets).

                                                  Also, imagine a woman having a baby and going back to work on Monday, and having to pay a full salary for care.. insane right?? Who needs babies.

                                                  But sure, salary difference..

                                                  • elmerfud 1 month ago
                                                    I'm not saying that all US companies offer decent healthcare options, but that's often because employees don't value that as a negotiation point. I did, and my son was in a horrible car crash and died after many days in ICU and many surgeries. My out of pocket cost was a few thousand to hit the max. Because I cared about healthcare coverage instead of a slightly higher salary.

                                                    People often forget that freedom of choice in the marketplace is freedom to allow some people to make dumb choices or bad choices. Often times when I hear people complaining about the lack of health care in the US It's because they prioritize short-term gains over budgeting for health care. They're gambling with their health, most people win but some people lose and they lose hard. They're hindsight isn't that they teach people that they should get health care and prioritize that in their budget. Rather they talk about socializing the costs because their irresponsibility somehow a burden to every other responsible person in society.

                                                    • spacedcowboy 1 month ago
                                                      This is not the case for me and mine. We had the best insurance money could buy, and a hospital still decided to prioritise money over patient need, which put my wife into a coma and ruined her (and my, for that matter) life.

                                                      I’ve posted elsewhere in the thread if you want more details (just look for the fucking long comments) but bottom line: money über alles is not the way to run a health service, IMHO.

                                                      • amanaplanacanal 1 month ago
                                                        This is a pretty privileged take. There are a lot of people who are never going to find a job with an expensive employer provided health plan.
                                                        • eastbound 1 month ago
                                                          > because they prioritize short-term gains

                                                          All you said is true. However, people are also competing with each other on lifestyle. It makes it mandatory to meet a certain level of financial performance if you want, for example, interesting friends or a girlfriend, let alone the same house as everyone, and kids. People who are a bit lower on the social scale then must part with the social insurance to increase their immediate lifestyle. Whereas when health insurance is mandatory for everyone, you won’t be competing with people who financially offer more during dates (except drug dealers and tax evaders; in Europe, professions which deal with cash like manual workers, have a much better lifestyle than engineers compared to their income).

                                                          • ginko 1 month ago
                                                            > My out of pocket cost was a few thousand to hit the max. Because I cared about healthcare coverage instead of a slightly higher salary.

                                                            Is having to pay a few thousand for emergency care considered low in the US?

                                                            • ghusto 1 month ago
                                                              First of all; fuck I'm so sorry :(

                                                              Secondly though; in Europe you don't have the potential to make a dumb choice because like it or not, you're getting decent healthcare.

                                                              • const_cast 1 month ago
                                                                1. The US health insurance market is not a free marketplace. It's almost as far away from a free marketplace as you can get. It's socialized medicine, just done in smaller, shittier fiefdoms.

                                                                2. I've never in my life seen anyone successfully negotiate health insurance with their employer. You get a pamphlet with your pre-determined shitty options and you have to pick one.

                                                                • alex43578 1 month ago
                                                                  That's something I've never understood around so many of these discussions, particularly post-ACA. I get there are some gaps around the out of pocket maximum, but if you have healthcare, even a serious medical event shouldn't be ruinous.

                                                                  Are all these anecdotes just people that had no coverage at all?

                                                                  • Scrapemist 1 month ago
                                                                    So in general you would argue the US system is better?
                                                                  • lmz 1 month ago
                                                                    They're working remote from the US so not sure how your first point is relevant.
                                                                • jeroenhd 1 month ago
                                                                  Michigan's average salary is a it below Austria's average salary. Not having American costs covered (healthcare etc) may change the salary impact a little.

                                                                  It's hard to tell without knowing what she does exactly, but as a white collar worker for a tech company she'll probably be earning similar to other white collar workers in Michigan.

                                                                  You won't be able to enjoy the same comfort working for a Bulgarian company in Silicon Valley, but this seems like a rather balanced pick.

                                                                  • onel 1 month ago
                                                                    Not everything in life is about money
                                                                  • r0ckarong 1 month ago
                                                                    "I didn't feel appreciated when I got sold back into slavery."